A relaxed waterfront dining experience known for their fresh, locally sourced seafood, craft cocktails, and wine selection. Signature dishes include the Square Grouper Seafood Stew, truffled lobster mac, and almond encrusted grouper. Open 11 AM - 2:30 PM and 5 PM - 10 PM, Wednesday-Sunday; closed Monday-Tuesday. Tip: Since the “To Be Seated” line can get long, ensure to join the outside line prior to 4:50 PM. 

An upscale island-style restaurant serving fresh seafood, New American entrees, decadent desserts, wine and beer, plus Sunday brunch. Menu highlights include their tuna tataki, conch and shrimp fritters, grilled prime NY strip, key lime pie, and salted caramel cheesecake brûlée. Reservations and special events may be accommodated. Open for dinner service 5 PM - 10 PM, Monday-Saturday; closed Sunday. 

An upscale Colonial-style eatery on the beach offering French Fusion cuisine and tropical views. Reservations are recommended. Dress code is “Casual Elegance”; no jackets or ties are required. Open 5 PM - 9:30 PM daily. Fun fact: Zagat’s noted Pierre’s as “one of the top all-around dining experiences” in the Florida Keys!

A boat tour operator located at Amara Cay Resort offering shared and private charters, snorkeling and sandbar tours, and equipment rentals. Bookings can be made directly through their website. Open 8 AM - 5 PM daily.

A popular marine park destination offering immersive experiences with dolphins, sea lions, sea turtles, and more. Visitors can enjoy interactive shows, a bottomless boat ride, a lagoon-side beach, and various animal encounter programs, including swimming with dolphins, snorkeling with rays, and meeting sea turtles and parrots. Open 9:30 AM - 5 PM daily.

A 7,500-square-foot museum and learning center at the Islander Resort featuring exhibits on Native Americans, pirates, and Spanish treasure fleets. The first floor focuses on the Keys’ anthropological history while the second floor serves as an adaptable space that hosts touring exhibits along with the Jerry Wilkinson Research Library here and a 35-seat theater screening informative documentary films. Open 10 AM - 5 PM, Tuesday-Sunday; closed Monday.

A quaint grocery store mainly known for their steak selection and fresh subs. Open 11 AM - 7 PM daily.

A full-service deli and grocery store. Open 24 hours daily.

A supermarket with a wide selection of groceries plus deli and bakery departments. Open 6 AM - 10 PM daily.