Top 9 Restaurants in St. George Island, Florida

Enjoy the slower pace of life that St. George Island offers and take some time to try the local cuisine. The island is not overrun by tourists and high-rise hotels, making it a great place to enjoy local seafood joints, where ‘’today’s catch’’ holds true to its name.

Here are our top suggestions for 9 restaurants in St. George Island, Florida.

The Beach Pit 

Photo courtesy of The Beach Pit

• Distance from Wander St. George Island: 1.3 miles

• Location: 49 W Pine Ave, St George Island, FL 32328

• Hours: 8AM-9PM Monday-Friday; 7:30AM-9PM Saturday & Sunday 

• Phone: (850) 799-1020

• Website: https://www.thebeachpit.com/ 

Specializing in Texas-style BBQ and fresh seafood, The Beach Pit brings a fresh taste to St. George Island. If that’s not enough, there are also fresh Apalachicola Bay oysters and draft beers on tap.

Tip: The outdoor patio is pet friendly, so feel free to bring along your furry friend.

Weber’s Little Donut Shop

Photo courtesy of Weber’s Little Donut Shop

• Distance from Wander St. George Island: 1.3 miles 

• Location: 65 W Gorrie Dr, St George Island, FL 32328

• Hours: Thursday-Saturday from 7:30 am until Sold Out 

• Website: https://www.facebook.com/weberslittledonutshopsgi 

Nothing says good morning like a freshly-baked case of donuts. At Weber’s Little Donut Shop, you can get small-batch artisan cake donuts made fresh daily. Donuts are $1.50 each, $9 per half dozen, or $18 per dozen. 

Tip: Weber’s is a small family-run business and only accepts cash, so be sure to keep a few bucks on hand in case you crave something sweet.

This is a popular spot among islanders so don’t be surprised if you see a line around the block. Unfortunately, since this is a small shop, they do not take pre-orders nor do they deliver. 

Blue Parrot Oceanfront Cafe

Photo courtesy of Blue Parrot Oceanfront Cafe

• Distance from Wander St. George Island: 1.3 miles

• Location: 68 E Gorrie Dr, St George Island, FL 32328

• Hours: 11AM-9PM daily 

• Phone: (850) 927-2987

• Website: https://www.blueparrotsgi.com/ 

If you're looking to sit oceanside and feel the salty breeze as you dine, then Blue Parrot Oceanfront Cafe is the place for you. On the menu, you’ll find everything from onion rings and shrimp tacos to raw or baked oysters.

The restaurant has a casual family-friendly atmosphere and also offers covered outdoor seating and an indoor air-conditioned dining room. Throughout the year, Blue Parrot hosts a variety of events, which you can find here. 

Tip: From March through October, you can rent jet skis daily from 10AM-6PM right next to the restaurant. For more information, you can call (850) 927-5150.

BJ’s Pizza and Subs 

Photo courtesy of BJ’s Pizza and Subs

• Distance from Wander St. George Island: 1.3 miles

• Location: 105 Gulf Beach Dr W, St George Island, FL 32328

• Hours: 11AM-9PM daily 

• Phone: (850) 927-2805

• Website:https://www.sgipizza.com/ 

On days that you’re craving something comforting, there is nothing better for the soul than some pizza and ice cream. Lucky for you, BJs Pizza and Subs sells both!

Did we mention that it is less than 2 miles from Wander St. George Island? This is a family-owned, counter-serve fast-food restaurant operating since 1990.

In addition to fresh pizza and Blue Bell hand-dipped ice cream, there is also a wide selection of salads, appetizers, calzones, sandwiches and wraps.

Tip: Be sure to check out the local favorite, buffalo chips, which is a homemade pizza dough covered in a blanket of hot wing sauce and parmesan cheese, then baked until crispy and served with ranch dressing.

Paddy’s Raw Bar 

Photo courtesy of Paddy’s Raw Bar

• Distance from Wander St. George Island: 1.8 miles

• Location: 240 3rd St E, St George Island, FL 32328

• Hours: 11AM-11PM daily 

• Phone: (850) 927-2299

• Website: https://www.paddysrawbar.com/ 

This is a low-key place where you can get together with friends, hang out, and enjoy some fresh seafood and drinks. A variety of oysters, seafood dishes, and appetizers, as well as sandwiches and wraps. Be sure to check out Paddy’s Facebook page for more information on live music events, trivia nights, and more. 

98 Eats

Photo courtesy of 98 Eats

• Distance from Wander St. George Island: 7.3 miles 

• Location: 191 US-98, Eastpoint, FL 32328

• Hours: 7AM-10PM Monday-Friday; 4PM-10PM Saturday; 12PM-9PM Sunday 

• Phone: (850) 670-1068

• Website: https://www.facebook.com/98EATS 

Bacon or sausage breakfast biscuits, build-your-own omelets, sweet baked cinnamon rolls, what else would you want in the morning? In case you are still hungry around lunchtime, 98 Eats has a variety of pizzas, chicken wings, footlong hot dogs, sandwiches, salads, and subs to choose from too. 

Tip: For our friends with allergies, the pizzas also come with gluten-free cauliflower crust.

Mangia 850

Photo courtesy of Mangia 850

• Distance from Wander St. George Island: 7.4 miles

• Location: 379 US-98, Eastpoint, FL 32328

• Hours: 11AM-3PM and 5PM-8PM Tuesday-Friday 

• Phone: (850) 323-2584

• Website:https://www.facebook.com/Mangia850/ 

Nothing warms your heart and tummy quite like a big bowl of pasta. Here you will find all of your Italian favorites like pasta carbonara, linguine, and even specialty items such as lobster ravioli.

If you are looking for lunch options, you’ll find classic Italian pastrami layered sandwiches, braised veal pot pies, baked lasagna, and of course, pizza. 

Tip: Check out the Facebook page for daily specials.

Brag-n-bones Barbecue

Photo courtesy of Brag-n-bones Barbecue

• Distance from Wander St. George Island: 10 miles 

• Location: 897 US-98, Eastpoint, FL 32328

• Hours: 11AM-7PM Tuesday-Thursday; 11AM-8PM Friday & Saturday; 11AM-6PM Sunday; Closed Monday 

• Phone: (850) 670-1060

• Website: https://www.bragnbonesbbq.com/ 

If you are looking for some good old fashion BBQ, this local restaurant has your fix. The menu features pulled pork sandwiches, smoked chicken, and a beef brisket plate, along with other BBQ classics. Check out the events page for upcoming discounts and special deals. 

Tip: Be sure to try the pork egg rolls and the pork quesadilla.

Up The Creek Raw Bar

Photo courtesy of Up The Creek Raw Bar

• Distance from Wander St. George Island: 13 miles 

• Location: 313 Water St, Apalachicola, FL 32320

• Hours: 12PM-8PM Tuesday-Saturday 

• Phone: (850) 653-2525

• Website: https://www.upthecreekrawbar.com/ 

Enjoy waterfront views in a laid-back atmosphere as you feast on a shrimp basket, some fried calamari, or perhaps oysters on the half-shell. There is a 50" flat-screen TV and a full bar with wine, beer, and liquor. Whether you want to watch a sports game or gaze at the wildlife over the ocean, you can do it all here.

If you don't have a place to stay yet, check out Wander St. George Island! For personalized recommendations on things to do around St. George Island, you can also text our concierge desk.