Wander
to give friends $250Get the Wander appto access Concierge

Wander Restaurant Guide: The 10 Best Restaurants in Pigeon Forge

 Natalie profile picture NatalieSep 13, 2024

Nestled in the heart of the Smoky Mountains, Pigeon Forge is a magnetic tourist destination, and it’s easy to see why.  

Known for its stunning natural beauty, this charming town provides a picturesque backdrop for outdoor activities like hiking, horseback riding, and scenic drives. It’s also home to Dollywood theme park and other family-friendly amusements, making Pigeon Forge the perfect blend of serene scenery and exciting attractions. 

A lesser-appreciated draw of Pigeon Forge is the culinary experiences it offers; this mountain town is a secret foodie’s paradise! From the classic Southern comfort spots and smoky BBQ joints you’d expect in the Deep South to authentic Cuban restaurants and unique distillery diners, Pigeon Forge has something to suit all tastes.

Keep reading to discover the best places to eat in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee, reasons to visit the Smokies, and where to stay in and around Pigeon Forge. 

The 10 Best Pigeon Forge Restaurants

When it comes to places to eat in Pigeon Forge, there’s no shortage of choices. We’ve narrowed it down to just 10 must-eat restaurants, in no particular order. 

Here are our favourite restaurants in Pigeon Forge and why we love them:

1. The Old Mill Restaurant 

Best for classic homemade Southern cuisine and comfort food in a historical setting

Location: 164 Old Mill Ave, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863

Located in a historic gristmill, the Old Mill is a popular choice for locals and tourists alike. Here, you’ll find hearty portions of homemade favourites like fried chicken, country-fried steak, and flakey biscuits served with a side of Southern hospitality! 

The Old Mill uses freshly milled grain in its breads, sweets, spirits, and cornmeal, making for a true homestyle experience. Its rustic setting, rich history, and hearty portions make the Old Mill a must-visit for anyone wanting a taste of Southern charm. 

2. Bennetts Pit Bar-B-Que 

Best for an award-winning Southern BBQ experience for fans of slow-smoked meat 

Location: 2910 Parkway, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863

Bennett’s Pit Bar-B-Que is a go-to destination for barbecue lovers seeking authentic, slow-smoked meats in the Smokies.

Tender ribs, rich pulled pork, and succulent brisket are carefully smoked over hickory wood for up to 14 hours. Classic Southern sides like baked beans, coleslaw, and cornbread complete the meal. It’s no wonder Restaurant Guru and TripAdvisor recommend Bennett's.

Excellent food is paired with friendly service and a warm atmosphere at this family-operated establishment. Whether you’re stopping in for a casual lunch or a full barbecue feast, Bennett’s Pit Bar-B-Que delivers an authentic Southern BBQ experience that’s hard to beat. 

3. Smokies Cuban Cafe

Best for quality authentic Cuban dishes and casual dining in a family-run restaurant 

Location: 3526 Parkway #4, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863

Smokies Cuban Café brings authentic Cuban flavors to the heart of Pigeon Forge. This family-run restaurant is known for its traditional Cuban dishes, including Cuban sandwiches, Ropa Vieja (shredded beef), and Lechón Asado (roast pork), served with sides like fried plantains, black beans, and rice. 

With friendly service and generous portions, Smokies Cuban Cafe is a go-to spot for those craving a taste of Havana up in the mountains.

4. Junction 35 Kitchen & Bar

Best for a lively night out with Southern BBQ dishes and spirits distilled on-site

Location: 2655 Teaster Ln #280, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863

Junction 35 is a unique dining and distillery experience in Pigeon Forge, combining Southern cuisine with handcrafted spirits. The restaurant offers a menu of hearty BBQ dishes like smoked brisket, pulled pork sandwiches, and bourbon-glazed wings, alongside burgers and southern favourites. 

The distillery produces small-batch spirits like whiskey, vodka, and rum, which are featured in many of Junction 35’s signature cocktails. Its industrial-chic setting makes this restaurant an excellent spot for casual dining and a lively night out. 

The combination of quality food, house-made spirits, and a vibrant atmosphere makes Junction 35 a must-visit destination in Pigeon Forge.

5. The Pancake Pantry

Best for traditional and unique American breakfast options in a cozy cafe with quick service

Location: 628 Parkway, Gatlinburg, TN 37738

The Pancake Pantry is a beloved breakfast spot which prides itself on being the first speciality pancake restaurant in Tennessee. 

Here, you’ll find classic favourites like old-fashioned buttermilk pancakes alongside unique options like sweet potato pancakes and Smokey Mountain buckwheat crepes. The Pancake Pantry also features other breakfast options and a luncheon menu of burgers and gourmet sandwiches. 

For a hearty breakfast, great value for money, and speedy service with a smile, visit this pancake palace just outside of Pigeon Forge. 

6. Local Goat

Best for homemade food made with locally sourced ingredients and craft beers

Location: 2167 Parkway, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863

Local Goat is known for its scratch-made menu, which highlights local ingredients. Lunch and dinner options range from salads to seafood, with favourites including steak dishes and gourmet burgers made with locally sourced beef. 

Local Goat’s Billy Bar specialises in craft beers. Its varied menu champions independent breweries based in Tennessee and beyond; an extensive wine list and craft cocktails are also available.

High-quality food and speciality beverages served with a casual vibe make Local Goat a great spot for dining and drinking in Pigeon Forge. 

7. Huck Finn’s Catfish 

Best for seafood cooked southern style, rare meats and all-you-can-eat options.

Location: 3330 Parkway, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863

Huck Finn’s Catfish is the go-to spot for Southern-style seafood specialising in (you guessed it!) catfish. The restaurant serves catfish fried, grilled, boneless, and on sandwiches and is renowned for its all-you-can-eat catfish experience. 

The menu also features other Southern BBQ staples, including fried chicken, coleslaw, and hushpuppies, as well as seafood options like shrimp and salmon. Their menu is complete with unusual offerings like frog legs and gator. Huck Finn’s is perfect for seafood enthusiasts with big appetites. 

8. Alamo Steakhouse

Best for premium hand-cut steaks and homemade sides in a Western-themed setting.

Location: 3050 Parkway, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863

Alamo Steakhouse is renowned for its high-quality, hand-cut steaks, grilled to perfection over an oak-fired grill for a rich, smoky flavor. Alongside aged steaks, the menu features wood-fired dishes like seafood and chicken, hand-ground burgers, homemade sauces, and seafood starters.

A commitment to homemade food, fiery flavours, and a rustic, Western-themed ambience make Alamo Steakhouse a must-visit restaurant for any foodie in the Pigeon Forge area. 

9. Mel’s Classic Diner

Best for a budget-friendly nostalgic 1950s diner experience with classic American dishes

Location: 119 Wears Valley Rd, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863

With a classic diner menu and a nostalgic 1950s vibe, Mel’s Classic Diner is ideal for any meal of the day. From pancakes and waffles to burgers and milkshakes, find diner favourites at reasonable prices served with a smile. 

With its retro décor and simple menu done well, Mel’s is a fun, family-friendly restaurant that captures the spirit of the classic American diner.

10. Five Oaks Farm Kitchen 

Best for Southern comfort dishes and sweet treats in a farmhouse-style setting

Location: 1638 Parkway, Sevierville, TN 37862

Five Oaks Farm Kitchen offers classic BBQ and American Southern dishes, upholding the warm hospitality of the Smoky Mountains. The menu features breakfast delights, a variety of smoked meats, and Southern favourites like dumplings, fried catfish, and cinnamon rolls. 

The restaurant sits in a charming rustic space with high ceilings and ample communal seating. Channelling the warm farmhouse spirit, Five Oaks Farm Kitchen promises a welcoming dining experience for all.

Why visit Pigeon Forge? 

Pigeon Forge is a popular family vacation destination that caters to diverse interests. Here are some of the best things to do in Pigeon Forge:

  • Enjoy the stunning views

  • Visit Dollywood

  • Go hiking, fishing, or ziplining in a beautiful landscape

  • Dine and drink at unique eateries and bars

  • Watch and listen to live entertainment

  • Enjoy family-friendly attractions

  • Soak up the charming, hospitable atmosphere

Read our Pigeon Forge Activities Guide for a deeper dive into Pigeon Forge attractions and Pigeon Forge Transportation Guide for details on getting around.

Where to stay in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

Ready to indulge in Pigeon Forge's culinary delights? Your food journey, paired with a stay in one of our dreamy homes, is the recipe for an unforgettable vacation. Check out our luxury vacation rentals in Tennessee.

Wander Pigeon Forge 

For those seeking a premium retreat in Pigeon Forge, Wander Pigeon Forge is a stunning 5-bed rustic property nestled in the Smoky Mountains. 

This charming lodge features an open-concept living area, a gourmet kitchen, and a game room complete with a 75" smart TV, pool table, and vintage arcade. 

Outdoor enthusiasts will enjoy the hot tub, fire pit, and spacious private lot for soaking up those breathtaking views. Meanwhile, ultra-fast wifi and a Tesla charging station will surely delight the tech-savvy guests in your party. 

Located in the exclusive Walden's Ridge community, just 7 miles from central Pigeon Forge, this property offers a perfect blend of high-end amenities and natural beauty for an unforgettable escape.

Wander Smoky Mountains

Wander Smoky Mountains is a contemporary sanctuary in Gatlinburg, Tennessee. The property boasts stunning mountain views, a hot tub, a fire pit, and a courtyard with a living green wall.

Complete with modern amenities like a games room, Smart TVs, and outdoor entertainment options, this 3-bedroom property is ideal for families and friend groups looking to escape to the hills just 7 miles from Pigeon Forge.

Share it with your friends