Wander Petre Island: Restaurant Guide

Savor the Flavors: Top Dining Destinations Near Wander Petre Island 

Photo courtesy of Stone House Bar and Grill

Photo courtesy of Stone House Bar and Grill

Situated near serene Lake Mahopac, a variety of dining options await food enthusiasts. From a European restaurant with a modern twist and Italian favorites to an organic spot perfect for any meal, the area offers something for everyone. Visitors can also enjoy a cozy country-style restaurant serving comfort food or dine lakeside at a modern venue with breathtaking views of the entire lake. To help you get started, we’ve created a guide with some top suggestions below!

Stone House Bar and Grill

Photo courtesy of Stone House Bar and Grill

Photo courtesy of Stone House Bar and Grill

Distance from Wander: 0.2 miles

Location: 562 US-6, Mahopac, NY 10541

Hours: 11:30AM-10PM Monday-Thursday; 11:30AM-11PM Friday & Saturday; 11:30AM-9PM Sunday

Phone: (845) 628-0616

Website: https://stonehouse-grill.com/ 

With over 30 years of experience, the Stone House Bar and Grill invites guests to savor Eastern European cuisine in mid-state New York. Boasting an array of tantalizing dishes crafted from the freshest ingredients and traditional cooking techniques, diners can indulge in everything from classic favorites like chicken parmigiana and chicken francese to innovative creations like branzino and surf and turf.

Brooklyn Organic Kitchen

Photo courtesy of Brooklyn Organic Kitchen

Distance from Wander: 0.1 miles

Location: 890 S Lake Blvd, Mahopac, NY 10541

Hours: 9AM-4PM Tuesday-Thursday; 9AM-7PM Friday & Saturday; 9AM-3PM Sunday; Closed Monday 

Phone: (845) 621-2655

Website: https://www.bokmahopac.com/ 

Brooklyn Organic Kitchen in Mahopac, New York, is a full-service restaurant that offers delicious traditional, vegan, and vegetarian dishes for all dietary preferences. Whether you're in the mood for breakfast, lunch, dinner, or brunch, they have you covered. Popular items include the Buffalo Cauliflower and Cauliflower Salad Pizza, alongside a variety of mouth-watering muffins.

Carriage House

Photo courtesy of Carriage House

Photo courtesy of Carriage House

Distance from Wander: 1.4 miles

Location: 887 US-6, Mahopac, NY 10541

Hours: 11:30AM-9PM Wednesday-Monday; Closed Tuesday  

Phone: (845) 803-8728

Website: https://carriagehousetavern.com/ 

With a cozy, relaxed country-style atmosphere and an enticing menu featuring starters like truffle chips and short rib poutine and entrees like braised short rib and chicken francese, diners at the Carriage House can expect a homely experience with a modern twist. From classic favorites like French onion soup to innovative dishes like fig flatbread, providing a delightful dining experience for guests looking for comfort and a warm atmosphere.

Lake House Restaurant and Bar

Photo courtesy of Lake House Restaurant and Bar

Distance from Wander: 0.3 miles

Location: 825 S Lake Blvd, Mahopac, NY 10541

Hours: 11:30AM-10PM daily 

Phone: (845) 621-5200

Website: https://lakehouserestaurantandbar.com/ 

Lake House Restaurant and Bar, located on the picturesque Lake Mahopac, is a great place to check out for waterfront views. They offer a mix of traditional favorites and innovative American dishes, all made with fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. Menu highlights include Burrata with imported prosciutto, Tuna Tartar, Filet Mignon Au Poivre, and Lobster Ravioli.

Tip: This restaurant is accessible by boat, and if you rent a pontoon, guest docks are available for patrons to tie up while dining!